According to Kisstimeline he used it on 5 occasions.
Paul used the bandit make-up live on these dates:
31. December, 1973 – Academy Of Music, New York.
8. January, 1974 – Fillmore East, New York.
26. January, 1974 – Academy of Music, New York.
Paul also used the bandit make-up on these dates:
26. December, 1973 – Rehearsal and label signing at the Fillmore East, New York.
25. January, 1974 – Photo Session with Raeanne Rubenstein, New York.
Read more at Kisstimeline here!
… or for the die hards go into extreme details here on Axeology
